Home India Government Comfortably Wins Vote On Opposition-Backed No-Trust Motion

Government Comfortably Wins Vote On Opposition-Backed No-Trust Motion

NEW DELHI:  The Narendra Modi government has won the vote of confidence in Lok Sabha by a comfortable margin at the end of a marathon, 12-hour debate session that saw the Prime Minister tear into the Congress and its chief Rahul Gandhi. In a never-before move today, Mr Gandhi had crossed the Lok Sabha floor at the end of a scathing speech, and hugged the Prime Minister. Late in the evening, PM Modi gave a point-by-point rebuttal to the attack. He also took on Mr Gandhi’s mother Sonia Gandhi and Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister Chandrababu Naidu, whose party had moved the no-confidence motion.

Here are the top 10 updates in this big story:

  1. In a house of 451 members, 325 voted in favour of the government, 126 were against. The halfway mark stood at 226, giving the government a two-thirds majority.
  2. The strength of the House slid down after Naveen Patnaik’s BJD, Telangana’s ruling party TRS and BJP ally Shiv Sena skipped the voting. Tamil Nadu’s ruling AIADMK voted in support of the government. There was no cross-voting.
  3. Prime Minister Narendra Modi showcased the achievements of his government  — electrification of 18,000 villages, healthcare for all, LPG for the poor, initiatives for farmers, One-rank one pension for soldiers, the flagship Goods and Services tax and the strengthening of economy.
  4. Targetting Sonia Gandhi over her recent statement on numerical strength of the parties supporting the no-confidence motion, PM Modi said he was reminded of 1999, when she joined other parties to challenge the NDA government led by Atal Bihari Vajpayee. “She stood outside Rashtrapati Bhavan and said, ‘we have 272 and more are joining us’. She destabilised Atal-Ji’s government and never formed one herself,” he said.
  5. Taking on Rahul Gandhi over his remarks on Rafale, PM Modi said, “They raised Rafale issue and I was surprised…  Due to one careless allegation in the House on Rafale, both nations had to release statements. Does this childish behavior befit anybody?”
  6. Earlier today, Mr Gandhi, leading the Congress offensive, alleged that the government’s deal with France for 36 Rafale fighter jets was massively overpriced and its claim that details could not be revealed was an “untruth”. He said when PM Modi went to France, “with some magic” powers, the price per plane increased to Rs. 1,600 crore, much more than Rs. 520 crore when the Congress was in power.
  7. France put out a statement saying the two governments had sealed a security pact in 2008, which legally binds them to protect classified information.The BJP has moved a privilege motion against Rahul Gandhi for his allegations against the PM.
  8. Before the no-trust debate started, there were many political twists for the BJP. The party had claimed the support of estranged ally Shiv Sena, which decided to stay away from the debate on chief Uddhav Thackeray’s orders.Naveen Patnaik’s BJD walked out, reducing the strength of the house and the majority mark.
  9.  PM Modi  tweeted this morning, calling for a “constructive, comprehensive and disruption free” debate on what he said was an important day in India’s parliamentary democracy. “India will be watching us closely,” he wrote.
  10. The no-confidence motion has been brought by Chandrababu Naidu’s Telugu Desam Party to push its demand for special status for Andhra Pradesh, which would involve extensive financial benefits. Mr Naidu had quit the NDA earlier this year over this issue.